Harrogate Borough Council

Liberal Democrats call for KPMG report on council reorganisation to be made public

3 October 2020

Liberal Democrats are calling on Harrogate Borough Council to release report on council reorganisation that KPMG were commissioned to put together.

The Council has grouped together with the other district councils to commission consultancy firm KPMG to produce a submission on the future of local government in North Yorkshire. In August it completed a preliminary report on the various options, on which councils based a preference for an East-West split.

Liberal Democrats have requested a copy of this taxpayer-funded report along with details of how much has been spent and what guidance KPMG has been given throughout the process. They say it should be made publicly available, however the council has so far resisted.

Although the Government has since gone silent on the matter, it asked councils to have submissions ready for September. Now, in October, there have been no signs of any consultation with residents or councillors.

A spokesman on behalf of the district and borough council Leaders, said:

The leaders of the seven district and borough councils in North Yorkshire commissioned KPMG to support the development of a business case for local government reorganisation should we be required to respond to government to submit a proposal.

When completed the report will need to be agreed by elected members within all seven councils before it is submitted to government and full details will be published.

 

Councillor Pat Marsh said:

Liberal Democrats have called on Harrogate Borough Council to release its KPMG report several times now. If Conservatives aren’t going to consult with residents on the future of local services, the very least they can do is be transparent about how decisions are being made.

Unfortunately this is typical of our Conservative-run Council. It won’t speak to residents or their elected representatives about huge issues like this, and when it does it is telling them what is happening at the eleventh hour, rather allowing any input. It would appear that Richard Cooper would rather rule by decree than risk hearing a differing view.

 

Judith Rogerson added:

The Conservatives are suggesting considerable restructuring to our system of local government. Residents need to be sure that what is being proposed is driven not just by what’s politically convenient, but what will deliver the best deal for their community. So far we’ve had no explanation of why local Tory leaders have opted for an East-West split of the county.

Our communities in Harrogate, Knaresborough, and Boroughbridge have closer economic, social and transport links to York and its surroundings than with the rural communities to the north of us. As things stand it’s difficult to understand why the East-West split is the preferred option.

Harrogate Borough Council must release the secret report immediately.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Latest Posts

Following customers’ complaints and a Trading Standards’ investigation, York Crown Court has sentenced a man to 10 month’s imprisonment for unfair trading offences. Liam Wilkinson, aged 25 of Eastbourne Road, Darlington paid a total £8,095 compensation for his victims, ahead of appearing in court on 30 October 2025 when he pleaded guilty to two offences. He was then sentenced on Friday 16 January 2026. City of York Council’s Trading Standards officers began investigating Mr Wilkinson’s activities in August 2024 after receiving complaints about his business, Brit-Plas. Brit-Plas leaflets were dropped around the city offering to replace UPVC guttering for a “genuine quotation” of £1,295. The leaflet claimed Brit-Plas is Yorkshire’s leading roofline specialists and “only when you are completely satisfied do you make the final payment.” The leaflet advertised this price to “recess your old wooden fascias, bargeboards, gutters and downpipes and replace them with new UPVC ventilated soffits, new UPVC fascias, new bargeboards and new guttering and downpipe system”. The leaflet offered free scaffolding and a 15-year guarantee. Four customers complained that when additional work was found to be required on their homes, it significantly increased the price. They said that the work completed was poor quality, and that their properties were left in a mess and were damaged because scaffolding wasn’t used as promised. After heavy rain, the customers found the new guttering leaked badly. An expert employed by Trading Standards found that the promises made by the trader, as set out in the marketing material, had not been delivered. They said that the approach to costing and execution of the work was most unprofessional, and aimed to mislead householders into believing that quality work would be delivered at a reasonable price. Despite the guarantee, the work had been found to have a more limited life, and some areas had already started failing. The workmanship fell below the standard normally expected. One customer described how they were repeatedly harassed for payment after the work had been completed. Workmen came to their house, banged on the window, shouted and swore. Cllr Jenny Kent, Executive Member for Environment at City of York Council, said: “Complaints about roofing and household repairs continue to top Trading Standards list and this is a particularly worrying case. We should be able to trust tradespeople to do good work on our homes, and prices should be honoured and not inflated to extortionate levels. Harassment is unacceptable and this case demonstrates how seriously the courts take these matters. “We urge consumers to get a few quotes from recommended traders, follow personal recommendations and look into companies as much as before agreeing to any work.” To share your concerns about poor quality workmanship, please call Trading Standards via the Citizens Advice Consumer helpline on 0808 223 1133.

23 January 2026
Go toTop

Don't Miss